What is the Difference Between Mutual Funds and Index Funds?

Mutual funds and index funds are popular options for diversifying your investment portfolio without having to manually select individual stocks. Both allow you to spread your investments across different assets and businesses, reducing your level of risk. Although these investment options are similar, investors should understand that there are some important differences between them before investing their hard-earned money.

What Is a Mutual Fund?

In India, investment vehicles are typically managed to pool funds from multiple investors. When a person purchases a share of a mutual fund, he actually becomes the owner of the fund and receives an equal share of the income and profits earned by the fund.

The Fund's dedicated investment manager is responsible for allocating the Fund's assets across a variety of asset classes, including stocks, bonds and other securities. These companies make important decisions on purchase, sale and sale of assets on behalf of shareholders with the goal of improving returns and managing risks effectively in the Indian investment country.

What are Index Funds?

An index mutual fund, or exchange-traded fund (ETF), has a portfolio structured to replicate or follow the components of a financial market index, such as the Standard & Poor's 500 Index. Mutual funds that invest in indices offer low operating expenses, broad market exposure, and minimal portfolio turnover. Whatever market conditions, the fund continues to invest in its benchmark index. Index funds are considered the best core portfolio holdings for retirement accounts such as Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) and 401(k) plans.

 Differences Between Index Funds and Mutual Funds


 In India, index funds are considered affordable when they follow a passive investment approach. The total rental rate (TER) of Indian accounts generally falls in the range of 0.20% to 0.50%. In contrast, actively managed funds often offer higher TERs, ranging from 1% to 2%.

The reason index funds have low returns is because of their passive management strategy. The fund does not require significant decision making by the fund manager to select individual securities to buy or sell. But it aims to correlate the performance of a specific market index like Nifty 50 or Sensex.

It is important to remember that while index funds provide cost benefits, they are not completely independent of income. Even if the fund's interest rate is 0%, investors may face costs and tax consequences associated with buying the shares. So, while index funds offer a great way to invest in a diversified portfolio, investors should consider the associated costs when making a decision.


A comparative analysis of mutual funds and index funds shows the difference between the two under different market conditions.

Diversified funds, especially those in equity, are performing better in the current market. This is the goal, based on a combination of financial and competitive forces. During market downturns in various sectors, these funds outperformed the market and offered higher returns. However, this is not the case most of the time.

Index funds hold a track record of actively managed funds more than 80% of the time. This is because the former is trying to match the top indices like Nifty 50. They start repeating their previous directions before beating them. In a bearish market, index funds provide poorer returns than performance funds.

This is why most investors prefer to keep a mix of mutual and passive funds. That way, it's better to get compensation from someone who can compensate for the damage someone else suffered.


Mutual funds are more flexible than index funds because their investments can respond to market changes and change portfolio holdings. Index files allow securities to be stored in a specific directory.


Both index funds and mutual funds have a certain level of risk, so investors should consider their risk tolerance and investment goals when choosing a fund.

Index funds are generally less expensive than mutual funds. They typically hold a portfolio of securities that spreads risk across different companies and sectors and minimizes the impact of individual security activity on the entire portfolio.

At the same time, mutual funds can result in greater risk in individual securities, shares or other types of investments. Mutual funds can outperform the market, but underperformance is more likely due to the investment decisions of the fund manager.


When choosing between an index and mutual fund, you should consider your investment goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon to determine the most appropriate option.

Index funds may be suitable for beginning investors seeking low risk and consistent returns. In contrast, it is more profitable for investors who are willing to take higher risk in search of higher returns.


Q. Which is better, mutual funds or index funds?

A. Generally, if you want to “set it and forget it,” index funds are a good bet. If you want the potential upside of a professionally managed fund or want to show your support for specific industries, like renewable energy, actively managed mutual funds will give you more options.

Q. Is it safe to invest in index funds?

A. Index funds often perform better than actively managed funds over the long-term. Index funds are less expensive than actively managed funds. Index funds typically carry less risk than individual stocks

Q. Is SIP and index fund same?

A. Index Fund SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) Investment has emerged. It combines the benefits of index funds, which offer broad market exposure, with the disciplined and gradual approach of SIPs, providing investors with a hassle-free and cost-effective investment strategy.

Q. Is index fund tax free?

A. No, investing in index funds is not tax-free. Capital gains generated from index funds are taxable.

Also Read: 
List the 7 best Government Health Insurance Schemes available in India

  • Share
logoSubscribe now